Flag Burning: A Crime Against America? Essay, Research Paper
Flag Burning: A Crime Against America?
Flag burning can be and usually is a very controversial issue with people. Many people believe that the American flag stands for something important and shouldn?t be destroyed in that manner. Others believe that flag burning is a statement that one should be able to make without major repercussions. Both sides have valid opinions and both sides state their case well. Although I am neither nor or against the burning of the flag, I believe the right should not be taken away. I believe that if a group of people have valid reasons and a valid point to make by obliterating a flag in such a way, they should have the right to do it.
The people who are against flag burning seem to generally be those who have served this country through war and through other such ways. They are older people who believe that this country is quite wonderful if not almost perfect. They have a strong sense of patriotism to this country and would die for what it stands for: liberty and freedom. They could compare it to the burning of crosses in front of a church or to the way the Nazis turned a very beautiful symbol into a racial and religious hate badge for murderers. Disrespect for tradition is what it boils down to. From a young age we are conditioned to blindly respect that flag hanging from a pole and to pledge out allegiance to it without even knowing what it truly is. It has been tradition for at least three generations. People who have been prisoners of war or people who fought for this country have a reason to respect it so much. The have fought long and hard for what we have and respect it. Some of our generation doesn?t realize how lucky we have it.
A child of this generation could debate how good and pure and wonderful this country is and could show you how we have had our liberty and freedom taken away to the point that we really don?t have any. True, we have had our freedom limited a bit, but that is only for the protection of ourselves from one another and from the government. As far as flag burning goes, people of this generation and other generations, have a right to show how they feel about what?s going on in this country. They feel that this county is doing something wrong and that is how they choose to express their grievance. The first amendment to the Constitution states that “Congress should make no law… .abridging the freedom of speech or of the press, or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances.” So according to that document, we have the right to get together peacefully and petition or rally or group together to try to get the government to listen. Sometimes it takes as much as burning a flag to get the attention of those in the White House and in Congress. As long as they aren?t hurting anyone and it is a peaceful act, they are guaranteed the constitutional right to do that.
Here is where it gets tricky and where my opinion come into it. I believe that as long as you aren?t hurting anyone else and as long as you have valid reasons for doing such a thing, it isn?t disrespectful to our nation. Granted, that could be what you are trying to do, but this nation is a great one, although it needs a little work. No one is perfect. I believe that if you are trying to get the government?s attention, you can find a better way to do it. I prefer the inverted flag. It stands for a sign of distress, which is what most of the flag burners seem to be trying to say.
Furthermore, if you look at the situation closely, it?s an oxymoron. The American flag is a symbol of liberty and freedom. It is a symbol of everything that we, as a country, have gone through to get where we are. If you remove the right for someone to show how they feel about such a symbol, you are removing their freedom. Hence, it?s an oxymoron.
I don?t personally think that I would ever try or feel the need to burn the flag, just because I think it is an irrational way to state something. If I ever did feel the need to burn one, I would have a valid reason beforehand that I would explain to everyone before I burned the flag. I personally think that there are better ways to go about doing things, ways that will attract less negative attention. Of course, I don?t think it is right for us to rule over what other people believe and how other people show it.
My stand point on this whole thing is let people believe what they want. Let people show what they believe however they want. We can?t take away that right. We can take it away when it begins hurting other people and infringing on their right to life, liberty and property. That?s where the line needs to be drawn. If, by burning a flag, you intentionally hurt someone physically, or end up damaging their property, that is when action should be taken against you. If we take away this fundamental right to express ourselves and how we feel about our nation (in ways such as flag burning), we can no longer say that we live in a true country of liberty and freedom. The “land of the free and the home of the brave” no longer exists when our right to free speech, press and petition are taken away.